Jacob Collieran unofficial fan site, home
· Last updated

The ledger

Capable why I stopped saying “talented”

I’ve said and written “Jacob Collier is the most talented human walking the planet” plenty of times myself — and so have countless others, including Quincy Jones, who wrote in 2014 that he had “never in my life seen a talent like this.”55

The trouble with the word talent is that it means different things to different people. To many, it sounds like a lucky gift, giving zero credit to the work behind it. Only a select few — readers of Daniel Coyle’s The Talent Code or Geoff Colvin’s Talent Is Overrated, for example — truly appreciate the sheer effort Jacob has put into his craft.

I’m deeply involved with AI these days, and there’s no equivalent trap there. Nobody ever looked at the latest AI model and thought it just got lucky with natural gifts; everyone intrinsically knows that top-tier capability takes massive work and effort, of humans and computers alike. That’s why this site says capable instead of talented. When I sat down to define what a complete musician actually does, it came down to ten things10 — each listed below with a source, a clip, and my own take, marked as mine.

  1. Voice
  2. Instruments
  3. Harmony & arranging
  4. Composition
  5. Production
  6. Conducting a room
  7. Improvisation
  8. Teaching
  9. Technology
  10. Collaboration

  1. 1. Voice

    His a cappella “Moon River” stacks his own voice with more than a hundred contributions from family, mentors, friends and collaborators. It won the GRAMMY for Best Arrangement, Instrumental Or A Cappella in 2020.21,22

    Jacob Collier: Moon River — Djesse Vol. 2, 2019: GRAMMY, arrangementYouTube video8:50Watch: Moon River

    The range is the least of it. Listen for how each voice in the stack has its own job.

  2. 2. Instruments

    He wrote eight of the eleven songs on his debut, In My Room, and arranged, recorded and produced it in his family’s music room, playing every instrument himself. Wikidata lists more than a dozen, from voice, piano, guitar and double bass to mandolin, harpejji and melodica.21,30 See the full list.

    Jacob Collier: Tiny Desk (Home) Concert — NPR Music, 2020YouTube video16:12Watch: Tiny Desk (Home) Concert

    Watch the Tiny Desk (Home) set and count the instruments he walks between. I lost count.

  3. 3. Harmony & arranging

    As of Nov 2, 2026, seven GRAMMY wins from 16 nominations, and every win is in an arrangement category: “Flintstones” and “You and I” (2017), “All Night Long” and “Moon River” (2020), “He Won’t Hold You” (2021), “In the Wee Small Hours of the Morning” (2024, shared with the säje arrangers) and “Bridge Over Troubled Water” (2025).22,21

    Jacob Collier: Flintstones — In My Room, 2016: GRAMMY, arrangementYouTube video3:11Watch: Flintstones

    A TV theme everyone knows, re-harmonised until it sounds like a dare. That is the whole trick, and nobody else does it like this.

  4. 4. Composition

    For Snarky Puppy’s Family Dinner Volume Two he wrote a new piece in 7/4, with a 5/4 B section, two drummers and a 7/4 march to finish. I was in the room in New Orleans when it was recorded.1,49

    Jacob Collier: Don’t You Know, with Snarky Puppy — Family Dinner Volume Two, New Orleans, Feb 2015 (I was in the room)YouTube video10:29Watch: Don’t You Know, with Snarky Puppy

    I have written a book on odd meters, and I still got lost in the bars of 5. By the last note I was stunned and speechless.

  5. 5. Production

    He has worked in Logic Pro since age 11, and his own publicist says he has broken track-count limits in DAWs. His session walkthrough of “Moon River” runs an hour and a half.38,23

    Jacob Collier: Logic session breakdown: Moon River — Livestream, 2019 (1 h 37 min)YouTube video1:36:51Watch: Logic session breakdown: Moon River

    Skip to any minute of the session breakdown. Every track has a reason.

  6. 6. Conducting a room

    He splits the audience into three to six parts, gives each a note (“the middle group F … to the left, I’ll give them C … to the right, I’ll give them A”), and moves them with a hand, “without saying a word.” His publicist counts 100,000 people brought together in audience choirs.41,23

    Jacob Collier: The Audience Choir — O2 Academy Brixton, London, 2022YouTube video4:59Watch: The Audience Choir

    I have been one of those voices. It feels like being a pixel in a picture you can hear.

  7. 7. Improvisation

    He conducted the National Symphony Orchestra “in a completely improvised performance,” live from the Kennedy Center.26,65

    Jacob Collier: Improvises the National Symphony Orchestra — Live from the Kennedy CenterYouTube video18:52Watch: Improvises the National Symphony Orchestra

    An orchestra is the hardest room to surprise. He surprises it on purpose.

  8. 8. Teaching

    He explains harmony to a child and to Herbie Hancock in the same video, leads masterclasses (UCSB, Feb 2025: “Your voice is only as strong as the people around you”), and runs his own retreat, Hideaway.43,44,65

    Jacob Collier: Music in 5 levels of difficulty, ft. Herbie Hancock — WIRED, 2018YouTube video15:41Watch: Music in 5 levels of difficulty, ft. Herbie Hancock

    He never talks down. That’s why it works.

  9. 9. Technology

    A 2016 MIT interview describes an early live harmonizer, designed by Ben Bloomberg of the MIT Media Lab, “sort of a cross between a vocoder and a live sampler,” with 12 voices, because “Jacob’s favorite chord has all 12 notes in it.” He also plays 5-string and 10-string signature Taylor guitars.38,35,26

    Jacob Collier: Performing on HARRY — Quincy Jones Productions, 2017YouTube video4:07Watch: Performing on HARRY

    He doesn’t wait for the tool. He helps build it, then plays it.

  10. 10. Collaboration

    More than 100 collaborators, including Coldplay, SZA, Shawn Mendes, John Mayer, Stormzy, Kirk Franklin and Hans Zimmer. “Bridge Over Troubled Water,” with John Legend and Tori Kelly, won him his seventh GRAMMY.23,26,22 See everyone he’s worked with.

    Jacob Collier: Bridge Over Troubled Water, with John Legend & Tori Kelly — Live at the Greek Theatre: GRAMMY, arrangement (2025)YouTube video10:04Watch: Bridge Over Troubled Water, with John Legend & Tori Kelly

    Everyone sounds more like themselves next to him. That is rarer than talent.

Jacob Collier in a polka-dot shirt singing into a microphone while playing a long-necked stringed instrument under blue light
Singing and playing at once. Moers Festival, Germany, May 16, 2016. Photo: Harald Krichel, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Jacob Collier singing with a headset microphone while playing an upright double bass, blue light behind him
On double bass at his album release show, YouTube Space LA, June 2016. Photo: Mpeha, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The ledger, as a set

One clip per lane, in order · 10 videos · 3 h 9 min

Tap any video card above to play it here, or press “Watch all 10 videos” to watch all ten in a row.

Early praise

They noticed early.

None of this is new. By October 2014, almost two years before In My Room, his own site carried a page of about forty short notes from musicians, broadcasters and critics. An earlier version with twelve went up in April 2013, when he was 18.55,21 Five of them:

  • I have never in my life seen a talent like this. One of my favourite young artists on the planet – absolutely mind-blowing Quincy Jones
  • Wow!! Jacob, your stuff is amazing Herbie Hancock
  • I am a big fan… great chords, great arrang[e]ments, great singing! Pat Metheny
  • Ridiculously creative, and wonderfully sung!!! Claude McKnight, Take 6
  • I have watched your videos many, many times Jamie Cullum

All five as listed on jacobcollier.co.uk/quotes, archived Oct 27, 2014.55 That Metheny line explains something. When I wrote to Pat about Jacob in 2015, he already knew.1

Signed

The most capable musician on the planet.

My view, Sean Fenlon · this is my opinion; the ten lanes are the evidence

Disagree? Make your case on r/JacobCollierMusic.